Any opinions on which would be a better choice between these two resort's? I've heard Capt. Dons is a bit tired, but haven't read anything like that.

We've enjoyed staying at Capt. Don's the past 4 trips. Please see my '02 trip report for details.

http://www.oldbonairetalk.com/newsgroup/messages/1022/31140.html?1021997999

We have not found "our" Oasis Cottage to be "tired". I do know that this past April there was some refurbishing going on in the Deluxe rooms near the pool. This is a good thing. We continue to tour other properties and we're planning to return to Capt. Don's again next Spring.

You can't go wrong with either. We've been to both and were very happy. We prefer Buddy's, but not by much.

We love BDR's drive-thru tank refills.

Buddy's acquired the place next door and is refurbishing some of those units. They were just starting with this project when we were there last (November 2004), and that caused some minor confusion and inconvenience. But nothing major.

They're both great spots. Enjoy!